WRD Corp Contact Us WRD Corp
Who We Are
Controls
Case Studies
Papers
Links

The "Buzz" on Embedded Development Productivity

© Doug Johnson WRD 7/31/02

Any embedded development discussion, is going to be a discussion about the "process": How does the programmer define the sequence of operation; how does the CPU interpret the definition for execution; what hardware architecture will be chosen; what pre-existing aids, i.e. hardware/software tools are available; and how do you manage it all, and deliver a well-executed, properly operating target. All of this is what I mean by the “process” i.e. “what is used, and how it’s used”.

"The search for the Holy Grail" in embedded development is a search for a more productive process. Recently, the buzz about this issue has been about as subtle as a F-14 on full after-burner. Everyone is looking for a way to improve the process, and there's been a lot of press on the subject.

Historically, most process improvements have fallen into one of the following areas:
  • Language: higher levels of abstraction such as C, C++, JAVA; industry specific such as Relay Ladder programming; ease of use for "normal" people such as BASIC or functional block (flow chart) type programming
  • Target hardware: memory density; flash memory; higher throughput; lower cost; improved functionality (peripherals); increased integration; etc.
  • Development tools: assemblers; compilers; emulators; simulators; debuggers; integrated development environments; etc.
  • Methodology: this has to do with the definition, and implementation of methods shown to provide productivity gains

 A discussion on the virtue of these “improvements” is difficult because, among other things, the word improvement implies the “newer” thing is “better”. For example I’ve almost never seen an article that says that C is better than C++, yet on small, cost constrained systems, this might likely be the case. Frequently people using the “latest” technology feel that the improvement is universal, and should be applied universally. This is a source of some of the zeal that sneaks into discussions concerning language and processors. The truth is more complicated, and requires a broader view of the objectives.

Recently there’s been some buzz on a couple of "new ideas" that are significant: System on Chip (SoC); and Platform Development. (SoC implies a single chip implementation, platforms are more general and aren't necessarily single chip) With both, you start with a known, pre-determined hardware/software base. You then make changes and additions required for the intended application. The improvement in productivity comes from the fact that your starting point is pre-done, and is (hopefully) trouble free. Also, as the platform is reused repeatedly, the developer gains familiarity (productivity). And finally, if the platform covers a wide application base, and is low enough in cost, it is possible to use the platform to cover an entire range of product offerings. This "single processor, single platform" approach provides a huge productivity opportunity, as it makes it possible for a single embedded engineer to design and support a wide range of products. (The alternative is having the developer support multiple products using multiple processors, a tall order, or having an embedded team, which is costly)

The “platform” concept is not really new. Many will recognize that a PC (embedded or not), with any commercial OS, is a platform. The difference is that neither the PC hardware, nor most OS's, were originally designed for the purpose of embedded controls. These newest SoC and Platform architectures are being designed from the ground up for embedded use. (See Tab-B for a presentation on platform development, reusability, and relevant article reprints from major trade publications.)

The WRD ProductMaker is a development platform designed specifically for the embedded controls market. Having spent an entire career designing embedded control systems, its clear how important reusability and system architecture is. 

The ProductMaker is a highly flexible hardware/firmware platform based on a powerful yet inexpensive 8 bit microprocessor (Z180), pre-engineered schematics (which cover most embedded control requirements), and an automated firmware configuration process which not only contains all peripheral drivers, task scheduler, floating point routines, & ISR's, keyboard scanning, LCD/LED displays, Rom monitor, etc., but integrates these into a seamless custom control engine that lets the system designed concentrate on the application instead of the integration details.

This platform is used extensively at WRD, and is key to WRD's ability to provide high quality, high functionality, low cost custom embedded controls, with short development times and low NRE.